I spent at least a month reviewing local jewelers through Better Business Bureau and all the online reviews I could find. After narrowing it down to about 3 or 4 jewelers, I called them all and ranked them based on my personal "gut impression." I'm so happy I went with Horseshoe.
I had a picture of a ring I wanted that would need to be custom made. Greg worked with us to create the perfect ring. His prices were far better than any other jewelers I talked to, and for much better quality. He let me examine the diamond under a microscope, something not everyone did. He was patient and always available by email or phone when I had questions.
I had such a good experience that I bought my fiance's wedding band from him, and we plan to return to him for any jewelry purchases in the future. I would highly recommend Greg and Horseshoe Jewelry to anyone and I look forward to continuing to visit his store.
Parking tip - you can park in the yellow zone right in front of the store, or there are a few casino garages that have free parking.